When is the “Big Idea” Too Big?

Preachers often aim to create a powerful “big idea” for their sermons, a central theme that organizes and communicates the passage effectively. While this tool can help in crafting clear and engaging messages, some question whether too much emphasis on the main idea can overshadow the text itself. Historical rhetoric emphasizes central ideas, but it’s crucial to remember that the main idea is a rhetorical device, not divine revelation. Preachers should ensure that the connection between the idea and the text is clear, moving from exegesis to homiletics. The focus should always remain on preaching God’s Word, not just the preacher’s idea. Effective sermons balance the clarity of a central idea with faithful communication of Scripture.